Problem
How to compare wet and dry dog food
The answer
Do not compare the percentages on the can to the percentages on the bag. Wet food is mostly water. Divide each nutrient by (100 - moisture), then compare. A label that says 9% protein and 80% moisture is about 45% protein on a dry-matter basis. A kibble that says 26% protein and 10% moisture is about 29%. The can is the higher-protein food once you strip the water.
The Base Score already does this. Wet and dry sit on the same scale. PawLens+ shows the full dry-matter nutrient table and lets you compare two foods side by side.
Free to try on iPhone. No account required.
What the label hides
“9% protein” is really ~45%
Typical wet food: 9% protein as-fed, ~80% moisture. Dry-matter protein is 9 ÷ 20 × 100 ≈ 45%.
The formula
Guaranteed analysis is printed “as-fed.” To convert one nutrient:
dry-matter % = as-fed % / (100 - moisture %) × 100
Do the same for fat, fibre, and ash if you have them. If moisture is missing, wet food is often around 75 to 82% water and dry food around 6 to 12%. That is an estimate, not a lab result.
Why some review-site charts look wrong
People looking at All About Dog Food and similar sites often say the “meat vs carbs” pie charts and the typical analysis do not add to 100. That is usually water on the label, plus rounding. Until everything is on dry matter, a 60% “meat” wet food and a 40% “meat” kibble are not a fair comparison.
What PawLens shows
Scan the barcode or photograph the guaranteed analysis. The Base Score uses the printed numbers on a dry-matter basis, and it is the same for every user. Tap any part of the score to see the math. PawLens+ adds the full nutrient table and side-by-side compare.
This is nutrition printed on a label, not a feeding trial and not veterinary advice.